Almazrouei, Mohammed A.; (2022) Possible Sources and Impact of Stress on Decision-Making in Forensic Science. Doctoral thesis (Ph.D), UCL (University College London).

Preview

Text 2022-12, Almazrouei M, Ready for Deposit.pdf - Accepted Version Download (2MB) | Preview

Abstract

Workplace stress has been shown to impact the quality of decision-making made by professionals in multiple domains, including medicine and policing. However, there remains a lack of research addressing the influence that workplace stress may have on the quality of forensic examiners’ decision-making. Forensic experts work in pressurised environments, and they make important decisions that may affect legal outcomes. Hence, it is critical to understand stress and its potential negative or positive impact on forensic experts’ decision-making. This research sought to explore the extent to which the forensic experts experience stress in the workplace, and its potential impact on the decision-making that they make in the forensic science process. The first part of the thesis presents data on the possible sources of stress and pressures, from surveys of practicing forensic examiners (Study 1 and Study 2). The findings suggested that some experts experienced high stress from workplace factors, including implicit pressures from stakeholders that interact with the experts to report certain forensic conclusions over others. Experts varied in their opinion whether stress affected their decision-making. The second part of the thesis explored the possible impact of stress on forensic science decision-making. An online method for testing the impact of stress on participants was developed, and it was found effective in inducing stress in human participants (Study 3). Then, the possible impact of this stressor on a fingerprinting comparison task with both novices and fingerprint experts was explored (Study 4). Findings revealed a complex relationship between stress and expert decision-making. Whilst stress improved the performance of both novices and experts on fingerprint assessments, stress also caused reduced risk-taking, especially when the fingerprints were difficult. Three underlying themes emerged from this research: the importance of addressing common stress factors, the positive impact of stress on decision-making, and the complexity of evaluating stress and its impact. These themes form the basis of a new model outlining the ‘Stressor-Stress Response in Expert Decision-Making’ which may contribute to the development of stress-optimisation strategies to enhance forensic expert performance.

Download activity - last month

Export as CSVXMLJSON

Download activity - last 12 months

Export as CSVXMLJSON

Downloads by country - last 12 months

Export as JSONXMLCSV

Archive Staff Only

View Item