UCL Discovery
UCL home » Library Services » Electronic resources » UCL Discovery

"It Was the Brain Tumor That Done It!": Szasz and Wittgenstein on the Importance of Distinguishing Disease from Behavior and Implications for the Nature of Mental Disorder

Moncrieff, J; (2020) "It Was the Brain Tumor That Done It!": Szasz and Wittgenstein on the Importance of Distinguishing Disease from Behavior and Implications for the Nature of Mental Disorder. Philosophy, Psychiatry, & Psychology , 27 (2) pp. 169-181. 10.1353/ppp.2020.0017. Green open access

[thumbnail of PPP_final version.pdf]
Preview
Text
PPP_final version.pdf - Accepted Version

Download (685kB) | Preview

Abstract

The current article looks at the distinction between bodily conditions, such as diseases, which may affect behavior, and situations that comprise self-directed behavior. This distinction was emphasized by the late Thomas Szasz, who recognized that regarding a situation as a disease or illness has important consequences that flow from the association of these concepts with the body. Wittgenstein's critique of the concept of mind helps to clarify and support Szasz's intuitions. Both Szasz and Wittgenstein suggest that we misunderstand the nature of 'mind,' and that mental states and events are not independent entities that can be discovered and described by natural science, but activities of living human beings that are manifested in, and recognized through, forms of public behavior. Mental disorders, which are also manifested in behavior, cannot, therefore, be aligned with biological conditions, unless there is evidence of an underlying disease. Attempts to expand the concepts of illness and disease by separating them from their bodily context, to accommodate mental disorders within a medical framework, only denude the terms of any distinctive meaning. Wittgenstein, like Szasz, suggests that what we characterize as mental illness, therefore, refers not to an illness or disease, but to patterns of unusual but still essentially self-directed behavior. These patterns can be understood as aspects of character, although they have a complex relationship to agency. The implications of this analysis for the justification of psychiatric coercion and the treatment of common psychological complaints are explored.

Type: Article
Title: "It Was the Brain Tumor That Done It!": Szasz and Wittgenstein on the Importance of Distinguishing Disease from Behavior and Implications for the Nature of Mental Disorder
Open access status: An open access version is available from UCL Discovery
DOI: 10.1353/ppp.2020.0017
Publisher version: https://doi.org/10.1353/ppp.2020.0017
Language: English
Additional information: This version is the author accepted manuscript. For information on re-use, please refer to the publisher’s terms and conditions.
Keywords: Disease concept, Mental disorder concept, Szasz, Wittgenstein philosophy of mind, Medical model of mental disorder
UCL classification: UCL
UCL > Provost and Vice Provost Offices
UCL > Provost and Vice Provost Offices > School of Life and Medical Sciences
UCL > Provost and Vice Provost Offices > School of Life and Medical Sciences > Faculty of Brain Sciences
UCL > Provost and Vice Provost Offices > School of Life and Medical Sciences > Faculty of Brain Sciences > Division of Psychiatry
URI: https://discovery.ucl.ac.uk/id/eprint/10105606
Downloads since deposit
239Downloads
Download activity - last month
Download activity - last 12 months
Downloads by country - last 12 months

Archive Staff Only

View Item View Item