UCL logo

UCL Discovery

UCL home » Library Services » Electronic resources » UCL Discovery

Towards an anatomy of protracted scientific controversy: perpetuated negotiation in the 'directed mutation' debate.

Jarvis, L.H.M.; (2008) Towards an anatomy of protracted scientific controversy: perpetuated negotiation in the 'directed mutation' debate. Doctoral thesis , University of London. Green open access

[img] PDF
U591505.pdf

Download (18MB)

Abstract

In 1988 an article from the Harvard School of Public Health sparked the 'directed mutation' debate. Its authors claimed that bacteria starved of their accustomed food were able to specifically control their genetic mutations and so adapt directly to use alternative food sources. Apparently, they were not at the mercy of random mutation to achieve adaptation as Neo-Darwinian theory demands. Rather, the authors claimed the bacteria chose their mutations and participated in their evolution as Lamarckian theorists had previously supposed. The controversy that followed was comprised of two sub-debates. The first concerned negotiation of this molecular genetic anomaly in bacteria. The second concerned the broader debate between Lamarckians and Darwinians, and contributed a new episode to a considerable historical legacy of similar dissent. The directed mutation debate has been protracted. I argue that it has been prolonged by active factors, which I refer to as 'perpetuating forces'. These include: the historical and cultural context of the controversy, the influence of scientific dogma on the evaluation of the anomalies, the role of defamation by association in Lamarckian resurrections, the interdisciplinary contest for authority and participants' styles of advocacy. I also analyse the role of the Internet in the protraction of this debate and provide quantitative analysis of the scale change caused by uptake of the debate in what I term 'the Internet forum'. To enable this analysis I apply boundary theory and the cartographic metaphor. I extend that theory in line with its' architects recommendations addressing the concept of 'old maps', and identifying boundary work at the interdisciplinary boundaries within the territory 'science'.

Type: Thesis (Doctoral)
Title: Towards an anatomy of protracted scientific controversy: perpetuated negotiation in the 'directed mutation' debate.
Identifier: PQ ETD:591505
Open access status: An open access version is available from UCL Discovery
Language: English
Additional information: Thesis digitised by ProQuest. Third party copyright material has been removed from the ethesis
UCL classification: UCL > Provost and Vice Provost Offices > UCL BEAMS > Faculty of Maths and Physical Sciences > Dept of Science and Technology Studies
URI: http://discovery.ucl.ac.uk/id/eprint/1444203
Downloads since deposit
286Downloads
Download activity - last month
Download activity - last 12 months
Downloads by country - last 12 months

Archive Staff Only

View Item View Item