Three philosophical problems about consciousness and their possible resolution.
Open Journal of Philosophy
, Article 1. 10.4236/ojpp.2011.11001.
Available under License : See the attached licence file.
Three big philosophical problems about consciousness are: Why does it exist? How do we explain and understand it? How can we explain brain-consciousness correlations? If functionalism were true, all three problems would be solved. But it is false, and that means all three problems remain unsolved (in that there is no other obvious candidate for a solution). Here, it is argued that the first problem cannot have a solution; this is inherent in the nature of explanation. The second problem is solved by recognizing that (a) there is an explanation as to why science cannot explain consciousness, and (b) consciousness can be explained by a different kind of explanation, empathic or "personalistic" explanation, compatible with, but not reducible to, scientific explanation. The third problem is solved by exploiting David Chalmers' "principle of structural coherence", and involves postulating that sensations experienced by us – visual, auditory, tactile, and so on – amount to minute scattered regions in a vast, multi dimensional "space" of all possible sensations, which vary smoothly, and in a linear way, throughout the space. There is also the space of all possible sentient brain processes. There is just one, unique one-one mapping between these two spaces that preserves continuity and linearity. It is this which provides the explanation as to why brain processes and sensations are correlated as they are. I consider objections to this unique-matching theory, and consider how the theory might be empirically confirmed.
|Title:||Three philosophical problems about consciousness and their possible resolution|
|Open access status:||An open access version is available from UCL Discovery|
|Keywords:||Consciousness, mind-body problem, brain processes, explaining consciousness, functionalism, experiential functionalism, physical explanation, empathic understanding, sensation-brain correlations, unique matching theory, hard problem of consciousness.|
|UCL classification:||UCL > School of BEAMS > Faculty of Maths and Physical Sciences > Science and Technology Studies|
Archive Staff Only