Must Science Make Cosmological Assumptions if it is to be Rational?
In: Kelly, TAF, (ed.)
The Philosophy of Science: Proceedings of the IPS Spring Conference 1997.
(pp. 98 - 149).
Irish Philosophical Society: Maynooth, Ireland.
105615_19 Must Science Make Cosmological Assumptions.pdf
Available under License : See the attached licence file.
Cosmological speculation about the ultimate nature of the universe, being necessary for science to be possible at all, must be regarded as a part of scientific knowledge itself, however epistemologically unsound it may be in other respects. The best such speculation available is that the universe is comprehensible in some way or other and, more specifically, in the light of the immense apparent success of modern natural science, that it is physically comprehensible. But both these speculations may be false; in order to take this possibility into account, we need to adopt an hierarchy of increasingly contentless cosmological conjectures until we arrive at the conjecture that the universe is such that it is possible for us to acquire some knowledge of something, a conjecture which we are justified in accepting as knowledge since doing so cannot harm the pursuit of knowledge in any circumstances whatsoever. As a result of adopting such an hierarchy of increasingly contentless cosmological conjectures in this way, we maximize our chances of adopting conjectures that promote the growth of knowledge, and minimize our chances of taking some cosmological assumption for granted that is false and impedes the growth of knowledge. The hope is that as we increase our knowledge about the world we improve (lower level) cosmological assumptions implicit in our methods, and thus in turn improve our methods. As a result of improving our knowledge we improve our knowledge about how to improve knowledge. Science adapts its own nature to what it learns about the nature of the universe, thus increasing its capacity to make progress in knowledge about the world. This aim-oriented empiricist conception of science solves outstanding problems in the philosophy of science such as the problems of induction, simplicity and verisimilitude.
|Title:||Must Science Make Cosmological Assumptions if it is to be Rational?|
|Open access status:||An open access version is available from UCL Discovery|
|Additional information:||Full text made available here with permission from the Irish Philosophical Society|
|Keywords:||Physics, metaphysics, theoretical unity, explanation, simplicity, methodology, induction, standard empiricism, aim-oriented empiricism|
|UCL classification:||UCL > School of BEAMS > Faculty of Maths and Physical Sciences
UCL > School of BEAMS > Faculty of Maths and Physical Sciences > Science and Technology Studies
Archive Staff Only